Monday, May 24, 2010

Map Woes Part 4

(...continued from Map Woes Part 3)

A recent visit to the Survey of India map sales office in Delhi was most frustrating. The people there were extremely reluctant to show me any maps without me first telling them the exact sheet number- they probably even need the latitude and longitude- and even then could only give me some large but pretty useless trekking maps of the Gangotri, Badrinath, and Shimla hills regions.

Pic: The impressive looking but ultimately disappointing trekking map from SOI (Bibek Bhattacharya)

They were careworn and mothballed, and the contour maps were kept firmly out of sight. I had made the mistake of going there without the sheet names and they effectively used it against me. And of course there’s that eternal suspicion. Just who is this person, they think. Why does he want topographical maps of border areas?

I had to settle for the trekking maps. Next time I go, I’ll take a sheet of paper with ALL the sheet names I can think of, and then some. And this time, if they demur, I will HAVE to do the unethical thing and wave my press card at them!

But then, a few weeks ago, I found this! I’d heard of it before, but I had no clue that it was freely available.

These amazingly detailed topographical maps are the legendary Series U502, made by the US Army Map Service for, yes the US Army, back in 1955. That makes them 55 years old, but boy are they out of this world. These sheets are the real thing- at least in the absence of SOI sheets. And the sheer scope of it is massive too, covering the entire subcontinent, including India, Pakistan, East Pakistan- ah the period piece ring of that- and Ceylon.

From what little of this vast map I’ve seen, most of the Himalayan regions seem to be pretty accurately mapped, at least after checking them against the others. And I can’t begin to describe the joys of learning the names of the many unforgettable places that I’ve seen in the mountains, and all that I’m yet to see. Entire ridge systems, rivers, towns have their names. Now these names might have gone out of use since all those years ago, but many of these I’ve managed to verify. The trend seems to be that of pretty accurate nomenclature.

Pic: The Dehradun Sheet of the AMS Series U502 (Bibek Bhattacharya)

The maps trip up in some places. For example, in the 'Simla' (sic) sheet, there’s a blank spot beyond the Pin Parvati pass where Spiti should be. It could be that the region had not been surveyed at the time. Then there are problems with the deeply contentious Indo-Chinese international border north of Gangotri. According to these maps, the entire Mana Gad (Gad is Garhwali for river) valley and its tributaries belong to China, although a glance through Kapadia’s Across Peaks and Passes in Garhwal gives us the real picture. At the end of the day there is no substitute for actually visiting these places.


Pic: Compare the section of the Chini sheet with Kapadia's map for the Mana Gad area in upper Central Garhwal. (Bibek Bhattacharya)

However, it must be said that where unsure, the Series U502 mentions it. They even have a handy 'Reliability Diagram' to the right of the map, where they rate the available information in that particular sheet from 'Good' to 'Fair' to 'Poor', and even list out the dates when the ground was surveyed. The oldest survey on the 'Chini' sheet, for example, are Medium Scale Topographical Maps from 1905!

Anyway, I’m completely in love. Oh, and finally, to end where I began, I now know the names of the eminences you see when you stand atop Chandrashila on a clear October day. It might be a meager victory, but to me that’s momentous!

And so, my map woes are at an end- at least until I renew the saga of SOI Topographical maps.


IndiBlogger - The Indian Blogger Community

12 comments:

Devalina said...

fabulous

i want more though. Stories about the mountains would be nice. Like not narratives, necessarily, but you know, stories.

Really like the whole series.

Sue said...

What Debo said, about the stories.

Very nicely written, Beq.

Anonymous said...

if u ever visit the old dharamshala library check out the topographical maps there. and Sven Hedin's reliefs...page after yellowed page...entire mountain ranges transcribed into this exquisite calligraphy :)

Beq said...

Hi Anon, thanks for telling me. I'd no idea. Must check it out!

olidhar said...

i didn't know. so many thanks!

Beq said...

About the AMS?

Anonymous said...

Asking questions аre really nice thing if you are not
underѕtanԁing something еntirely, however
this post providеs nice understanding even.

Feel free to surf tо my homepage: blog network

Anonymous said...

This is my first time visit at here аnԁ i am actually happy to read everthіng at
sіngle place.

Herе is my web ѕite; Daniel Chavez Moran

Anonymous said...

Right nοw it loоks like Movаble Type is
the bеst blogging platform availаble right now.

(from what I've read) Is that what you're using on your blog?


Stoρ by my homeрage: link building

Anonymous said...

Goоd resрonse in гetuгn of this iѕѕue with fіrm aгguments
аnd describing all regaгdіng that.

My web page :: http://www.galder.biz/

Anonymous said...

Right herе iѕ the right web sіte for anybοdy whο wishеs to understаnd this topic.
You rеalіze so much its almost tough tо argue
with you (not that I аctually ωoulԁ want to…HаHa).
You сеrtainly put а brand new spin оn a
ѕubjeсt that has been wгitten about for decades.
Excellent stuff, just wondеrful!

Look at my page ... online reputation management companies

Anonymous said...

Ӏt's not my first time to visit this website, i am visiting this web page dailly and get nice data from here daily.

my website - Lloyd Irvin